Grotto (Ricambio Ombretto Metallico)

I’ve been hunting for a deep emerald that actually reads green on my lids instead of muddy black, and this metallic refill nails it. The shine is intense without needing a wet brush, and it blends out beautifully for a one-shadow look.

Finally, a metallic green that doesn't look black in dim light—this one stays a true, rich emerald. The refill snaps into my palette without any fuss, and a little goes a long way for that bold, shimmery pop.

I've been hunting for a true emerald for ages and this refill is exactly that—one swipe and my lids looked like wet jewel tones. It's also vegan which makes me feel better about wearing it daily. The metallic payoff is insane for a tiny pan, and I love that it drops right into my empty case.